The secrets of making (raw and vegan) chocolate

Everyone loves chocolate… and so do I 🙂 ! As I love to understand the various health aspects of food that we eat, I was curious in making a healthy chocolate. Of course I am not the first person to discover this. Nevertheless, it took me some time to experiment and find the proper resources that helped me understand the process of making chocolate. So, I would like to share this information.

Here is the list of the ingredients for my personal chocolate recipe. To truly benefit from cacao, we need to make sure that our ingredients are raw ingredients if possible. As sweetener, I tend to use xylit as it has good sweetening properties and it has no negative effects on our body (it is even good for your teeth health!). Here are all ingredients you need:

  • 250g raw cacao butter (250g)
  • 6 tablespoons raw cacao powder (feel free to add more)
  • 8 tablespoons xylit (ground to be powder so that it can dissolve more easily)
  • Almond creme (2 tablespoons)
  • Spices: a tiny bit of (ground) salt, vanilla (very important!), cinnamon, chili powder


Crystallization properties of cacao butter

Have you ever tried to melt the chocolate and then to put it into the fridge? What was the result? When I tried it, I experienced crumbly and soft chocolate which melts to easily. The surface was not nice and shiny, but rather dull and unpleasant. This is due to the fact that cacao butter has different types of crystals with different melting properties.This is why one needs to temper chocolate. Wikipedia summarizes this nicely:

The final process is called tempering. Uncontrolled crystallization of cocoa butter typically results in crystals of varying size, some or all large enough to be clearly seen with the naked eye. This causes the surface of the chocolate to appear mottled and matte, and causes the chocolate to crumble rather than snap when broken. The uniform sheen and crisp bite of properly processed chocolate are the result of consistently small cocoa butter crystals produced by the tempering process.

The fats in cocoa butter can crystallize in six different forms (polymorphous crystallization). The primary purpose of tempering is to assure that only the best form is present. The six different crystal forms have different properties.

The different crystal types with their varying melting temperatures and properties are the following (also taken from Wikipedia):

Crystal Melting temp. Properties
I 17°C (63°F) Soft, crumbly, melts too easily
II 21°C (70 F) Soft, crumbly, melts too easily
III 26°C (79°F) Firm, poor snap, melts too easily
IV 28°C (82°F) Firm, good snap, melts too easily
V 34°C (93°F) Glossy, firm, best snap, melts near body temperature (37°C)
VI 36 °C (97 °F) Hard, takes weeks to form

This is why we will need the tempering process as described below.

Armed with this important secret of making chocolate, we can now start to actually make chocolate…


Step 1 – Make xylit powder

Use a coffee grinder or a small blender to grind the xylit. Xylit crystals will not dissolve easily in cacao butter, so grinding the will spread the sweet taste of xylit well in the chocolate.


Step 2 – Melt the cacao butter

The easiest way to do this is to but a bowl with cacao butter into a bowl with warm water (it should not be to hot). Monitor the temperature (best with a infrared thermometer) until the cacao butter has reached approximately 43°C. This way we make sure that no ingredients of the cacao butter will be denatured by heat.


Step 3 – Blending ingredients together

Now it is time to blend all ingredients into a nice dark chocolate mass. I like to use a blender on a small speed level. Blending helps for building up many small crystal seeds. These little seeds will then later help to build up a fine cacao butter crystal structure.


Step 4 – Tempering

During blending, the chocolate mass will cool down. Let it cool down to about 28°C. Now we want to make sure that our chocolate contains as many type V crystals as possible. For this we will heat up the mixture up to 32°C and thus we will give more time to the type V crystals to form. You can heat up the chocolate mass again in a water bath. Make sure that you stay below 32°C while observing carefully the temperature. At any time, it is important to keep stirring in order to spread the heat evenly.


Step 5 – Mold the chocolate

It is now safe to pour the chocolate mass into any mold you like. Let it cool down at room temperature. After some time, be amazed about your home made healthy chocolate that has a nice, shiny texture and a firm snap 🙂 . Enjoy!!!



  1. kencole says:

    hey! I tried doing this two different ways and i’m not getting grew results 🙁 not sure what i’m doing wrong….

    the first way i melted the cacao butter in a saucepan on low heat and then whisked in cacao powder and maple syrup, then i poured into the molds and put it in the fridge for maybe like 3 hours. they looked great and tasted great and snapped like real chocolate, but once out of the fridge for like 15min, it started to melt on my fingers…

    the second way i tried following more of what you had above. I used a thermometer, double boiler, melted the cacao butter at around 100 degrees F, mixed the butter, cacao powder and maple syrup in the vitamix on low, it cooled down, and then back on the double boiler until it reached 90 F and then into the molds but no fridge this time. they didn’t get hard like real chocolate and had grey spots on the surface….

    🙁 please help 🙁

  2. Alex says:

    Dear Kencole, thanks for you comment!

    Cooling in the fridge will let various crystals form which have has property a rather low melting temperature. In consequence, you will end up with the result that you described.

    Grey spots indicate that the wrong crystal types grew in your chocolate. It might be an issue with the type of thermometer. Try to use an infrared one and stir steadily while heating to make sure that the temperature spreads out evenly across the chocolate mass. You really have to be precise with heating up the chocolate mass again. If the temperature is too high, it will melt the Type V cacao crystals again and various crystal types will form when cooling down. That is why you should not go higher than 32°C. Stirring also allows many small crystal groups to form. They will act as seeds such that Type V crystal groups will form faster.

    tl;tr … make sure you follow the precise temperature protocol in order to achieve good results. This is the alchemical key for making chocolate. I still think its kind of magic to make chocolate 😉 .

  3. mike says:

    Hi – Can i substitute cacao butter with cocnut butter instead?

  4. Can I use raw yacon powder and not the other sweetners? PLUS 8 drops of stevia liquid

    I just want some nice HARD CACAO!


    maybe some COCONUT butter too??

  5. Alex says:

    Hi Mike, coconut butter won’t do the trick… cacao butter has a different form of crystal forming and won’t get that crispy at room temperature.

    Dear Lynna, you could add almond butter/cream for instance which will yield a softer and less crispy texture. Not sure how coconut butter would affect the crystal forming of chocolate. As for the sweeteners, you should give it a try yourself 😉 .


Leave a Comment

Tags: , ,

September 1, 2014 Food, My Life